What to order at Sonic, according to dietitians and nutritionists

Here's what experts suggest ordering after you pull into the American drive thru

Chef introduces three new diets for better health in 2024

Chef Diane Hendricks shares several new diets, Flexitarian, Dash and Mind, to try for improved health in 2024 on ‘Fox & Friends.’

When the Sonic Drive-In beckons, you may feel tempted to heed its call. 

But as it goes with many other fast-food chain visits, you may want to keep things in moderation for the sake of your waistline and overall health. 

Kim Yawitz, a registered dietitian and the owner of Two Six Fitness in St. Louis, Missouri, pointed out, the large Oreo Peanut Butter Shake has more calories than she typically eats in an entire day — and six times the recommended daily limit for added sugar.

WHAT YOU SHOULD ORDER AT WENDY'S, ACCORDING TO DIETITIANS

Yawitz said that in her professional view, while she wouldn’t call anything on the Sonic menu particularly healthy, she did note that some choices are slightly better than others.

"You won't find any minimally processed foods here (unless you count the lettuce on your burger), and most of the menu is high in calories, saturated fat and added sugar," she said. She added that while some menu items have a decent amount of protein, they also contain quite a bit of fat and sodium. 

sonic order split

When in a pinch or taking a road trip, here are the top six meals to order, according to nutritionists. (iStock/SonicDriveIn.com)

Yawitz suggested looking for items that are lower in calories, fat and sodium.

Below, Yawitz and Lara Clevenger, a Florida-based registered dietitian nutritionist at Omni Nutrition LLC, shared what to order when dining at Sonic.

WHAT YOU SHOULD ORDER AT MCDONALD'S, ACCORDING TO NUTRITIONISTS

Fox News Digital reached out to Sonic for comment.

Kids’ Crispy Tenders

"I’m not sure I’ve ever recommended chicken tenders as one of the healthiest restaurant options, but I guess there’s a first time for everything," admitted Yawitz. 

kids chicken tenders

Ordering from the kids' menu can be a good move when you're watching what you eat at fast-food chains. (SonicDriveIn.com)

"The Kids' Crispy Tenders are the lowest-calorie, lowest-fat entrée on the menu — coming in at 180 calories and eight grams of fat," said Yawitz. 

"Surprisingly, this is also one of the lower-sodium options, with 490 milligrams per serving (not counting sauce or sides)," she continued.

Typically, she said, she tells her clients to limit their sodium intake to 500 milligrams at each of three meals, and this is one of the few options at Sonic that stays below that target. 

WHAT TO ORDER AT CHICK-FIL-A, ACCORDING TO NUTRITION EXPERTS

Plain Junior Burger

jr burger sonic

Skip the chicken and go for a plain junior cheeseburger — the healthiest burger on the Sonic menu. (SonicDriveIn.com)

Not feeling chicken fingers? 

Go for the Plain Junior Burger. 

The Plain Junior Burger has 330 calories, 15 grams of fat, 710 milligrams of sodium and 14 grams of protein — "and it’s the healthiest burger on the menu by far," Yawitz said. 

WHAT TO ORDER AT TACO BELL, ACCORDING TO DIETITIANS AND NUTRITIONISTS

"It’s a little low in protein (with just 14 grams), so you’ll need to eat higher protein foods at other meals," she added.

chicken sandwich sonic

If you want to cut down on calories, try skipping the extra condiments. You could ask for the Chicken Slinger Sandwich without mayonnaise. (SonicDriveIn.com)

Chicken Slinger Sandwich

"The Chicken Slinger sandwich certainly won’t win any nutrition awards, but it’s one of the healthier options on this menu," said Yawitz. "One sandwich has 360 calories, 18 grams of fat, 690 milligrams of sodium, and 15 grams of protein."

To cut down on calories and fat, Yawitz suggested ordering it without the mayonnaise.

WHAT YOU SHOULD ORDER AT SUBWAY, ACCORDING TO NUTRITION EXPERTS

You can also skip one-half of the bun and eat it as an open-faced sandwich to consume fewer carbs.

Quarter Pound Double Cheeseburger

Again, no nutrition rewards here, but if you’re in a squeeze, this is a filling choice, the experts indicated.

double quarter pounder

The Quarter Pound Double Cheeseburger may not win any nutrition awards, but it is a good source of protein. (SonicDriveIn.com)

This cheeseburger clocks in at 560 calories, 35 grams of fat, 35 grams of carbs and 26 grams of protein, according to Sonic's online nutritional brochure. 

"This option gives you a good source of protein while limiting excessive carbohydrates," Clevenger said.

Crispy Tenders - 5 Piece

chicken tenders sonic

Consider grabbing the five-piece crispy tenders to go and enjoy with a side of carrots or a spinach salad at home. (SonicDriveIn.com)

The five-pieced crispy tenders come in with a whopping 36 grams of protein with 37 grams of carbs and 530 calories, said Clevenger.

By skipping the bun and opting for tenders, you save calories from omitting bread, she said.

CLICK HERE TO SIGN UP FOR OUR LIFESTYLE NEWSLETTER

If you’re eating at home, pair these with a serving of baby carrots or a spinach salad for some fiber, she suggested.

Bacon Breakfast Burrito

bacon and cheese breakfast burrito

Sonic even has potential breakfast options like the bacon breakfast burrito — but experts warn against eating bacon regularly. (SonicDriveIn.com)

Clevenger said that if you’re eating breakfast at Sonic, go for the bacon breakfast burrito. 

"With around 470 calories and 25 grams of protein, it’s a great on-the-go breakfast to fuel your morning," she said.

Still, considering that bacon is one of the worst foods for your health, consider ordering only as an occasional treat, the experts said.

For more Lifestyle articles, visit www.foxnews.com/lifestyle.

Perri Ormont Blumberg is a contributing lifestyle reporter for Fox News Digital.

Authored by Perri Blumberg via FoxNews February 2nd 2024