Fintech, or financial technology, is reshaping the future of finance by offering new opportunities and challenges for consumers, financial institutions, regulators and policymakers. It can foster innovation, competition, inclusion and development, but it can also pose risks to financial stability, integrity and consumer protection. In developing countries, where fintech adoption is growing rapidly, weak regulatory frameworks, inadequate infrastructure, low financial literacy and cyber threats amplify these risks.
Fintech’s Challenges and Risks for Developing Markets
Disruptive fintech is not without its drawbacks. Fintech disruption can also have negative financial impacts on developing markets, especially on the traditional financial institutions and the regulatory frameworks that govern them. In this blog post, we will explore some of the challenges and risks that fintech poses to developing markets and how regulators and policy makers can address them.
{This source is from a report by the International Monetary Fund (IMF) titled "The Rise of Digital Money", which analyzes the implications of digital currencies and fintech for financial stability and regulation
DESTABILIZING INCUMBENT FINANCIAL PLAYERS
A report by the International Monetary Fund (IMF) titled "The Rise of Digital Money", analyzes the implications of fintech for financial stability and regulation. One of the main challenges that fintech disruption poses to developing markets is the loss of market share and revenue for the incumbent financial institutions.
Fintech startups often offer lower fees, higher interest rates and better customer experience than the traditional banks and microfinance institutions. This can erode the profitability and sustainability of the incumbents, who may struggle to compete with the fintech innovators. Moreover, fintech startups may also bypass or undermine the intermediation role of the incumbents, reducing their value-added and relevance in the financial system.
CAPITAL ADEQUACY, LIQUIDITY AND SOLVENCY
Another challenge that fintech disruption poses to developing markets is the lack of adequate regulation and supervision. This risk is highlighted in a 2018 report from the Bank for International Settlements (BIS), which warned that fintech startups may pose challenges for financial stability and consumer protection.
Fintech startups often operate in a regulatory gray area, exploiting loopholes or gaps in the existing laws and standards. This can create unfair competition, consumer protection issues, cybersecurity risks and financial stability concerns. For example, fintech startups may not comply with anti-money laundering (AML) and combating the financing of terrorism (CFT) requirements. This exposes them, and their clients, to illicit activities and sanctions.
SOCIAL AND ECONOMIC EXCLUSION
Yet another challenge that fintech disruption poses to developing markets is the potential for social and economic exclusion. Fintech startups often rely on big data analytics and artificial intelligence (AI) to assess the creditworthiness and risk profile of their customers. This can create biases and discrimination against certain segments of the population, such as women, minorities, rural dwellers and low-income earners. Fintech startups may also exclude customers who do not have access to digital infrastructure, such as smartphones, internet connectivity and electricity. This can widen the digital divide and exacerbate existing inequalities in developing markets (Brookings, 2019).
Global Risks from Developing Financial Markets
Fintech disruption can lead to positive evolutions in developing markets. However, loosely regulated and unsupervised fintech may also pose significant risks and challenges to the stability and integrity of the global financial system.
Fintech can create new sources of global systemic risk, such as cyberattacks, operational failures, fraud, money laundering, terrorism financing, and consumer protection issues. Fintech can also disrupt existing financial intermediaries and markets, with global footprints, such as banks, payment systems, securities exchanges, and insurance companies, and create new forms of market power and concentration.
The lack of adequate regulation and supervision of fintech in developing financial markets can also lead to negative spillover effects on the broader global markets. For example, if a fintech company in a developing country fails to comply with anti-money laundering and counter-terrorism financing standards, it can facilitate the flow of illicit funds across borders and undermine the global efforts to combat these threats.
Similarly, if a fintech company in a developing country suffers a cyberattack or an operational breakdown, it can disrupt the cross-border payment systems and networks that link the global financial markets. Moreover, if a fintech company in a developing country gains a dominant position in a certain market segment or service, it can create unfair competition and distort the level playing field for broader global market participants.
Fending Off Potential Fintech Disruption
It is essential, therefore, that fintech is regulated and supervised in a way that balances the potential benefits and risks of this emerging sector. This requires a coordinated and collaborative approach among the relevant authorities and stakeholders at the national and international levels. The regulators and supervisors need to adopt a risk-based and proportionate framework that ensures the safety and soundness of fintech activities and entities, while fostering innovation and competition.
The regulators and supervisors also need to enhance their capacity and expertise to monitor and oversee the fast-changing fintech landscape, especially in developing markets, to fend off potential harmful disruptive fintech. Finally, regulators and financial watchdogs need to strengthen their cross-border cooperation and information sharing to ensure consistent and effective oversight of fintech activities and entities that operate across jurisdictions.
Helping Startups Navigate the Business Formation Maze
Because developing market fintech’s impact global financial markets, fledgling ventures in the developed world must exercise caution at the outset – when establishing themselves as legal entities, such as a limited liability company (LLC). If you want to start an LLC in Texas, Startup Savant has the ultimate collection of online resources and guides for entrepreneurs.
Avoid the potential pitfalls that many fintech’s in the developing world fall victim to. From startup business ideas, to helpful podcasts and tips, the company offers everything you need to begin your entrepreneurial journey. You'll be able to create the business of your choice with a vast array of free guides, content, and other helpful tools.
