When Jack Hierholzer moved back to Pensacola in the Florida panhandle, it felt like a homecoming.
“My kids were born in Pensacola, and so we have a lot of friends in the neighborhood, we have some family here,” he told AFP in a phone interview.
But less than three years later, he’s thinking of leaving the city after seeing his home insurance premium more than triple to $6,500 — due in part to the rising costs to insurers of extreme weather fueled by climate change.
“I work from home full time, so I could live anywhere in the country where I have a high-speed internet connection,” he said.
“So if it gets bad enough, we’re mobile, we can move,” he added. “And we will.”
Rising premiums
Natural disasters destroyed assets worth more than $140 billion in the United States last year, of which close to $90 billion was insured, according to data from Munich Re.
The reinsurance firm — which provides insurance to insurance companies — estimated that around 70 percent of the total damage was caused by Hurricane Ian, which devastated Florida’s west coast last September.
The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) is unequivocal about the impact of human activity on global warming, and recently noted that man-made climate change “is already affecting many weather and climate extremes in every region across the globe.”
As extreme weather events have become more common, the costs of insuring against them has risen sharply.
Home insurance premiums in the United States rose by nine percent on average last year — and by far more in some states — according to the Insurance Information Institute (III), an industry trade body.
The main drivers of higher premiums have been the rising cost of reinsurance, and the growing cost of rebuilding materials.
Reinsurance costs have increased by between 30 and 40 percent year-on-year, according to Mark Friedlander, director of corporate communications at III.
“As we see reinsurance continue to move upward in terms of year-over-year renewal costs, clearly climate risk is the primary factor for that,” he told AFP.
Rebuilding costs, meanwhile, have risen by around 30 percent over the last five years, due largely to pandemic-related supply chain disruptions.
Regional variations
At the state level, a host of local factors have added to the challenges caused by climate change.
In California, for example, insurance premiums are well below the national average at around $1,300, according to III, due in large part to state laws that give the government a greater say over any increases.
While this should be great news for homeowners, it has also made it more challenging for insurers, who have found themselves unable to pass on the rising costs of insuring properties against increasingly severe wildfires.
State Farm, one of the largest insurers in the state, recently announced it would stop accepting new applications for homeowner insurance in California due to its “rapidly growing catastrophe exposure.”
And in Florida, premiums have soared due to a combination of factors, including historically generous laws for homeowners looking to sue their insurers, and the growing cost of payouts related to hurricanes, according to III.
“We have the man-made factors combined with the climate risk factors, and that’s a formula for extreme levels of insurance premium,” Friedlander said.
While homeowners have seen their premiums surge, the number of people without home insurance across the United States has remained relatively steady at around seven percent, according to III.
This is because US mortgage holders are required to have home insurance, meaning only those who can pay off their loans in full can take the risk of doing without it.
With his insurance premium now costing more each month than his mortgage repayments, Hierholzer in Pensacola is weighing this option as he considers his next steps.
“If insurance is so high that I’m effectively buying a new house every 12 years, then it would be much smarter to not insure the house, just pay the mortgage off and then roll your dice,” he said.
