Israel's 9/11 Times Seven
In our last post (A Moment Of Clarity In The Mideast), we wrote that the ongoing Hamas attack on Israel was the worst attack the country had seen in fifty years, since the Yom Kippur War of 1973.
A Moment Of Clarity In The Middle East
— Portfolio Armor (@PortfolioArmor) October 7, 2023
The latest Hamas attack highlights the insanity of the status quo.https://t.co/rmaj6gAL8l
That's still true, but on Sunday we got preliminary casualty figures indicating that Israel had at least 600 dead so far, which makes this roughly the equivalent of several 9/11s for the small country.
On a % of population basis it’s ~7x bigger than 9/11.
— David Pinsen (@dpinsen) October 8, 2023
And unlike 9/11, this catastrophe has reportedly included mass rape.
Survivors of the Hamas attack on the music festival have been interviewed by @tabletmag:
— Visegrád 24 (@visegrad24) October 9, 2023
"Women were raped at the area of the rave next to their friends bodies, dead bodies.
"Several of these rape victims appear to have been later executed.” pic.twitter.com/1gsXsnU2jg
Leftists In America React
One of the notable reactions to the gruesome news out of Israel was this one, by a Somali in Minnesota.
"not like this" then like what. show us LOL
— Najma Sharif (@overdramatique) October 7, 2023
There were also of course mass rallies in support of the Palestinian cause in New York and other American cities, prompting some to note the lack of disquiet about the nature of the Hamas offensive.
Ngl it’s insane that Hamas went on a medieval rape and murder rampage through southern Israel and the next day there’s a rally for Palestine in New York. Like let the pie cool for a second damn
— Daniel (@growing_daniel) October 9, 2023
Others pointed out that leftists are showing what they'd like to do to normal Americans if they get the power to do so.
So Was This All Part Of A Mossad Plan?
That was the argument of a post shared by one of our fellow contributing editors yesterday ("No, the Hamas Invasion Was Not an Israeli ‘Intelligence Failure’").
Our view is that it was almost certainly a massive military and intelligence failure on the part of Israel, which raises the question we mentioned in the title of this post.
How Did Hamas Get The Drop On Israel?
The thread below gives a cogent explanation of how Hamas managed to launch such a large surprise attack on the Jewish State.
Factor 1: Israel has built a formidable set of fortifications on the border with Gaza.
— Yago (@EdanYago) October 8, 2023
However, fortifications are useless without people to man them.
A political decision was taken to deploy almost the entire combat force to the West Bank.
In particular… pic.twitter.com/7sS1yMEBHF
Factor 2: Of the few remaining soldiers, many had been released home for the holidays, leaving only a skeleton crew defending.
— Yago (@EdanYago) October 8, 2023
This was made even worse by…
Factor 4: In advance of the invasion, Hamas fired a massive salvo of rockets as a distraction and suppressing fire.
— Yago (@EdanYago) October 8, 2023
They used this diversion as cover for… pic.twitter.com/TAw4SSGvTZ
Factor 6: A first and primary target in these forward bases were communications equipment. Destroying these, Hamas took out significant parts of the IDF command and control system, plunging the area into the fog of war.
— Yago (@EdanYago) October 8, 2023
They sowed further confusion by…
Factor 8: It appears that Hamas used civilian protesters as cover to plant explosives by the border fence. These were then used to breach the fence during the assault.
— Yago (@EdanYago) October 8, 2023
As the author noted in response to commenter, this doesn't entirely explain the long delays in getting troops to the affected areas, but initial evidence there suggests leadership failures of massive proportions. After this crisis is over, Prime Minister Netanyahu will have a lot to answer for.
In Case You Missed It
In a post last week, Beating The Market While Hedging, we wrote about a conservative investing approach that can beat the market sometimes--and strictly limit your downside risk when it doesn't.
It's possible to beat $SPY in an up market while hedging.
— Portfolio Armor (@PortfolioArmor) October 6, 2023
Here's a real-world example. https://t.co/s3pIJcmZYs
Here's that example we alluded to in the tweet above.
This is the portfolio our web app created at the beginning of April for an investor with $30,000 to put to work who was unwilling to risk a decline of more than 13% over the next six months:
And here's how that hedged portfolio did over the next six months:
Over the next six months, that hedged portfolio was up 23.28%, net of hedging and trading costs, versus 5.18% for the SPDR S&P 500 Trust ETF (SPY).
As we wrote there, they won't all do that well. The portfolio created a week before using the same inputs lost 7% over the next six months. That's why we recommend splitting your money up into a couple of tranches, opening one hedged portfolio now, and then the next one in two or three months, to get different names and smooth out returns.
If You Want To Stay In Touch
You can create hedged portfolios on our website. You can also follow Portfolio Armor on Twitter here, or become a free subscriber to our Substack using the link below (we're using that for our occasional emails now).