Thomas Edward Williams is the 'Indiana Slasher,' police said, and he died in a Texas prison in 1983 for an unrelated crime
Former NYPD inspector breaks down Gilgo Beach evidence
Fox News contributor Paul Mauro joins 'America's Newsroom' to discuss the evidence against Gilgo Beach murder suspect Rex Heuermann as he is reportedly expected to face a fourth count.
Three women "played dead" while the "Indiana Slasher" stabbed them multiple times, sexually assaulted one of them and left them to bleed out in a cornfield.
The suspect, nicknamed the "Slasher" or "Indiana Slasher," eluded police nearly 50 years and became a real-life boogeyman of Hancock County.
The survivors — Kandice Smith, then 13, Sheri Rottler Trick, then 11, and Kathie Rottler, then 14 — learned this week they had outlived the man who tried to kill them in 1975.
The "Slasher" was finally identified through genetic genealogy as Thomas Edward Williams, who died in a Galveston, Texas, prison in November 1983 while serving time for unrelated crimes, Indianapolis Police said Thursday.
Survivors of the "Indiana Slasher's" 1975 attack — (left to right) Kandice Smith, Sheri Rottler Trick and Kathie Rottler — talked during Thursday's press conference. (Indianapolis Police Department)
"He was hunting," said Steve Gibbs, a detective with the Marion County Sheriff's Office at the time who has investigated the cold case since 2018.
"I would hate to use the word professional, but he was a hunter ... of victims," Gibbs told the Indy Star. "Once you're in his car, it's like being caught in a spiderweb. There's no getting out."
The three girls were hitchhiking to get to an amusement park, but Williams drove past their destination, drove them to a secluded cornfield in Hancock County and bound two of them.
They were all trapped in his "spiderweb."
He raped 11-year-old Rottler Trick and stabbed her three times in the throat and another 15 times in her chest, police said.
Then he turned his attention to Smith and Rottler, and slit both of their throats.
Indianapolis Police reveal the identity of the "Indiana Slasher" was Thomas Edward Williams, who died in a Texas prison. (Indianapolis Police Department)
The "Slasher" left, thinking they were all dead, but Smith and Rottler had enough strength to crawl for help.
They finally flagged down three passersby, who called 911 and saved their lives.
One of the first responding officers compared the cuts to the girls' necks as appearing similar to that of an accordion, the Indy Star reported.
SWATTING ADVANCED FROM PRANKS TO ‘DIGITAL TERRORISM’: EXPERT
"I do forgive this man," Rottler Trick said during Thursday's press conference. "I had to in order to continue my life. I hope anybody who’s in this situation can please do the same."
Smith said, "I'm at peace now."
Three victims of the "Indiana Slasher" are surrounded by members of the Indianapolis Police Department. (Indianapolis Police Department)
Retired Indianapolis Police Sgt. David Ellison, from the department's cold case unit, said during the press conference three samples of DNA evidence recovered from the crime scene pointed to one unknown man.
The department partnered with DNA Labs International, a private forensic lab that used funding help from media company Audiochuck, which used the latest genetic testing to identify Williams' son and daughter.
CLICK HERE FOR MORE TRUE CRIME FROM FOX NEWS
After nearly five decades, law enforcement had the "Slasher."
"Today’s announcement is nearly 50 years in the making, but it shows the dedication and perseverance of our detectives and partners," Indianapolis Deputy Chief Kendale Adams said in a statement.
"IMPD will hold criminals accountable, no matter how long it takes. While we would like to do this immediately, this may take years and even decades, and we never stop looking for answers."
Chris Eberhart is a crime and US news reporter for Fox News Digital. Email tips to
