Peaches vs. plums: Is one 'better' for you? Experts reveal the truth of these 'stone fruits'

One fruit offers more vitamin C, while the other stands out for its higher fiber content

Tiny tortoise tries to eat colorful fruits and vegetables for snack

A tortoise at California's San Diego Zoo Wildlife Alliance was recently spotted trying to eat fruits and vegetables for a colorful snack. See the Burmese star tortoise! 

Peaches and plums are both known as "stone fruits" – and both are members of the Prunus genus. 

A stone fruit is a fruit that has a large pit, or "stone" in its center, according to the website Foodwise. This hard pit is not the fruit's seed, but rather protects the seed.

While peaches and plums come from the same family, they are not the same – and they do have their nutritional differences. 

AS FALL APPROACHES, WHICH COLOR OF APPLE IS 'BETTER' FOR YOU AND WHY: RED, GREEN OR YELLOW?

But is one "better" for you than the other? Fox News Digital spoke to experts to find out. 

"Peaches and plums are both rich in vitamins, but peaches provide a slightly higher amount of vitamin C, which supports immune health and skin repair," Kelly Springer RD, MS, told Fox News Digital via email.

Ripe peaches and plums for sale at a farmers market in baskets.

Peaches and plums both belong to the same plant genus — but they do not have the same nutritional content. So which is "better" for you?  (iStock)

The New York-based Springer is founder of Kelly's Choice, LLC, a dietitian company. 

Plums, on the other hand, "stand out for their higher fiber content, promoting digestion and gut health." 

Peaches, meanwhile, "tend to have a higher water content" than their purple cousins. 

Plums, however, naturally contain sorbitol, "a sugar alcohol that aids in relieving constipation," she said. 

APPLES VS. ORANGES: WHICH OF THESE FRUITS IS 'BETTER' FOR YOU?

"This is why prunes, which are dehydrated plums, are recommended for constipation relief," she added. 

Benjamin L. Smith, PHC, creator of "The Ultimate Health Model," told Fox News Digital in a phone interview that eating locally grown is also an important consideration.

Peaches and nectarines in a farmer's market.

Peaches, seen here, have a higher water content than plums.  (iStock)

"You want to eat local and organic," he said.

Eating food that is grown locally is "more beneficial to the mitochondria," he added.  

FARMERS MARKET FOOD-SHOPPING SECRETS IN 5 KEY CATEGORIES: 'GET THE BEST QUALITY'

Both peaches and plums, due to their sugar content, are "good in limited quantities," he said. 

"Any fruit — just limit the amount," he said, especially if a person has a chronic condition such as diabetes. "Just try to limit the amount of sugar." 

"Both fruits are nutritious in their own ways," Dr. Chris Mohr of Louisville, Kentucky, told Fox News Digital. Mohr is fitness and nutrition adviser at Fortune Recommends Health.

"Both fruits are nutritious in their own ways."

Peaches have more vitamin A than plums – meaning they are better for vision and immune health – but plums contain "anthocyanins," Mohr said, "which help reduce inflammation." 

"Choosing between peaches and plums really comes down to your personal preferences," he said.

"Both are also comparable in fiber content, which can support digestive health and help with weight management — but really, any fruit is amazing, so enjoy them all." 

Peaches and plums close up.

People should aim to eat a "rainbow of fruits," said one expert – a rainbow that includes both peaches and plums. (iStock)

Springer offered a similar sentiment.

CLICK HERE TO SIGN UP FOR OUR LIFESTYLE NEWSLETTER

She said she tells her clients to eat "a rainbow of fruits" – and that both peaches and plums have their pluses. 

For more Lifestyle articles, visit www.foxnews.com/lifestyle

"In the case of peaches and plums, orange and yellow fruits like peaches are packed with carotenoids for immune support — while purple fruits like plums contain anthocyanins that protect against oxidative stress and inflammation," she said. 

Christine Rousselle is a lifestyle reporter with Fox News Digital.

via September 6th 2024