Farmers argued that fully halting the use of dicamba could financially hurt them
Bill Wirtz warns American farmers about government regulation: This should be a ‘key focus’
Luxembourg writer and commentator Bill Wirtz shares advice for U.S. farmers after German farmers protest government regulations.
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency said on Wednesday that farmers can use some existing supplies of weedkillers based on the chemical dicamba, despite a federal court ruling last week that halted sprayings.
The decision is a win for farmers who planned to use dicamba products sold by Bayer BAYGn.DE, BASF BASFn.DE and Syngenta on genetically modified soybeans and cotton, and for the agrichemical companies.
Environmental activists have objected to dicamba herbicides because they are known to drift away and damage other crops that are not resistant.
GLOBAL FARMER PROTESTS SHOULD BE A WAKE-UP CALL FOR AMERICA
But farm groups had warned the court ruling, if fully enforced by the federal government, could financially hurt growers who will plant their next crops in the spring. The groups had said most growers had already determined which seeds and chemicals they will use and may struggle to shift away from dicamba herbicides or crops that tolerate the chemical.
"We are very appreciative of EPA's decision to let us get through the 2024 growing season by using any product already in the delivery pipeline," said Josh Gackle, president of the American Soybean Association and a North Dakota soybean farmer.
U.S. District Court Judge David Bury in Arizona last week vacated the EPA's registrations of dicamba-based weedkillers from 2020, saying the agency violated procedures mandating public input. The ruling affected Bayer's XtendiMax, BASF's Engenia and Sygnenta's Tavium, commonly used herbicides on U.S. farms.
A farmer in Arkansas looking at his soybean plants in 2017. They showed signs of dicamba damage. (The Washington Post / Contributor via Getty Images)
Bayer soybeans that resist dicamba-based herbicide are the No. 2 most-planted soybeans in the United States, though not all are sprayed with the chemical.
The EPA said it authorized the sale and distribution of dicamba products "that were already in the possession of growers or in the channels of trade and outside the control of pesticide companies" before the court ruling on Feb. 6.
The agency "received ample evidence that millions of gallons" of dicamba products meant to be sprayed on crops had already entered trade channels, according to a statement.
Bayer and Syngenta welcomed the decision to allow their products to be used this year. BASF said it stopped U.S. sales and distribution of Engenia because of the court ruling, but EPA's order should enable farmers to use the herbicide to control weeds developing resistance to chemicals in 2024.
